David Corfield Thomas Kuhn, Modern Mathematics and the Dynamics of Reason

An article I’ve written, (pdf), published in Yafeng Shan (ed.) Rethinking Thomas Kuhn’s Legacy, pp. 51-76.

Abstract: It is now 30 years since a group of philosophers and historians published a collection of articles (Gillies (ed.) 1992) which took as their central question the usefulness for the philosophy of mathematics of Kuhn’s constructions in the philosophy of science. Important work was done to see whether the concepts of ‘revolution’ and ‘paradigm’ made sense there. However, a feature of the collection which should raise doubts about the universality of its findings was the restriction, except in a single case, to work done prior to 1900. In this article I discuss what form a historically-oriented philosophy of modern mathematics should take, and the role it could play in developing Michael Friedman’s post-Kuhnian theory as described in his ‘Dynamics of Reason’ (2001) and later publications.

For more on Michael Friedman, see here, and my talk Dynamics of Reason Revisited (slides).

For the first in a proposed series of narrative accounts of homotopical and categorical algebra, the example I give of a contemporary revolution, see

  • Lior Yanovski, A Story of Algebra and Categories I: Algebraic Theories [arXiv:2611.07927]

The purpose of these notes is neither to survey the landscape of such frameworks nor to develop rigorously the theory underlying any one of them. Rather, it is to invite the reader, whatever their background, to enjoy a compelling story about some of the ideas involved and why one should care about them. All the statements are “well known” even if some are more difficult to extract, in the exact form they are presented here, from the existing literature. Full proofs are included only when they are both simple and instructive. Likewise, references are chosen primarily for the explanations they offer, rather than to document the origins of every idea, result, or technique.

Freed from the demands of a strictly logical or chronological order, the story can unfold somewhat nonlinearly, using “advanced technology” to motivate, streamline, or contextualize more basic con- structions. This mode of exposition is unlikely to suit the novice. It is intended rather for readers who have already heard many of these stories but still find them difficult to hold together. It assumes fluency in the language of ∞\infty-categories — or at least the ability to feign it convincingly — while drawing on little beyond the basic facts. Above all, it is written for the young in spirit: those who appreciate being shown how to think about things and would rather be persuaded that a definition is inevitable than merely assured that it is useful.

Last revised on November 15, 2026 at 17:28:29. See the history of this page for a list of all contributions to it.