Contents

topos theory

# Contents

## Idea

A geometric morphism is locally connected if it behaves as though its fibers are locally connected spaces. In particular, a Grothendieck topos $E$ is locally connected iff the unique geometric morphism to Set (the terminal Grothendieck topos, i.e. the point in the category Topos of toposes) is locally connected.

## Definition

A geometric morphism $(f^* \dashv f_*) : F \underoverset{f_*}{f^*}{\leftrightarrows} E$ is locally connected if it satisfies the following equivalent conditions:

1. It is essential, i.e. $f^*$ has a left adjoint $f_!$, and moreover $f_!$ can be made into an $E$-indexed functor.

2. For every $A\in E$, the functor $(f/A)^* \colon E/A \to F/f^*A$ is cartesian closed.

3. $f^*$ commutes with dependent products – For any morphism $h\colon A\to B$ in $E$, the canonically defined natural transformation $(f/B)^* \circ \Pi_h \to \Pi_{f^*h} \circ (f/A)^*$ is an isomorphism.

## Properties

### Relation to connectedness

If $f$ is locally connected, then it makes sense to think of the left adjoint $f_!$ as assigning to an object of $F$ its “set of connected components” in $E$. In particular, if $f$ is locally connected, then it is moreover connected if and only if $f_!$ preserves the terminal object. However, not every connected geometric morphism is locally connected.

### Over $Set$

Over the base topos $E =$ Set every connected topos which is essential is automatically locally connected.

This is because the required Frobenius reciprocity condition

$f_!(A \times f^* (B)) \simeq f_!(A) \times B$

is automatically satisfied, using that cartesian product with a set is equivalently a coproduct

$A \times B = \coprod_{a \in A} B \,,$

that the left adjoint $f_!$ preserves coproducts, and that for $f^*$ full and faithful we have $f_! f^* \simeq Id$.

The pair of adjoint functors $(f_! \dashv f^*)$ in a locally connected geometric morphisms forms a “strong adjunction” in that it holds also for the internal homs in the sense that there is a natural isomorphism

$[f_!(X), A] \simeq f_* [X, f^* A]$

for all $X, A$. This follows by duality from the Frobenius reciprocity that characterizes $f^*$ as being a cartesian closed functor:

by the Yoneda lemma, the morphism in question is an isomorphism if for all objects $A,B, X$ the morphism

$Hom(X, [f_!(A), B]) \stackrel{}{\to} Hom(X,f_*[A,f^*(B)])$

is a bijection. By adjunction this is the same as

$Hom(X \times f_!(A), B) \stackrel{\simeq}{\to} Hom(f_!(f^*(X) \times A), B) \,.$

Again by Yoneda, this is a bijection precisely if

$f_!(f^*(X) \times A) \to X \times f_!(A)$

is an isomorphism. But this is the Frobenius reciprocity condition on $f^*$.

### Coreflectivity

Locally connected toposes are coreflective in Topos. See (Funk (1999)).

### Other characterizations

• Let $(\mathcal{C}, J)$ be a site and $S$ be a sieve on the object $U$. $S$ is called connected when $S$ viewed as a full subcategory of $\mathcal{C}/U$ is connected. The site is called locally connected if every sieve is connected. For a bounded geometric morphism $p:\mathcal{E}\to\mathcal{S}$ the following holds: $p$ is locally connected iff there exists a locally connected internal site in $\mathcal{S}$ such that $\mathcal{E}\simeq Sh(\mathcal{C},J)$. (cf. Johnstone (2002), pp.656-658)

• Caramello (2012) gives syntactic characterizations of geometric theories whose classifying topos is locally connected.

The same paper also contains the following characterization:

• A Grothendieck topos is locally connected iff it has a separating set of (coproduct) indecomposable objects.

### Variations in the context of the Nullstellensatz

Johnstone (2011) studies several subclasses of locally connected geometric morphisms in the context of Lawvere‘s theory of cohesion and the Nullstellensatz. He calls a locally connected morphism $p$ stably locally connected if $p_!$ preserves finite products. According to the above remark this implies that $p$ is connected. Slightly stronger is the preservation of all finite limits by $p_!$: these $p$ are called totally connected geometric morphisms.

## Examples

• If the terminal global section geometric morphism $E \to Set$ is locally connected, one calls $E$ a locally connected topos. More generally, if $E\to S$ is locally connected, we may call $E$ a locally connected $S$-topos.

• Let $X$ be a topological space (or a locale) and $U\subseteq X$ an open subset, with corresponding geometric embedding $j\colon Sh(U)\to Sh(X)$. Then any $A\in Sh(X)$ can be identified with a space (or locale) $A$ equipped with a local homeomorphism $A\to X$, in such a way that $Sh(X)/A \simeq Sh(A)$. Moreover, $j^*A \in Sh(U)$ can be identified with the pullback of $A\to X$ along $U$, and so $Sh(U)/j^*A \simeq Sh(j^*A)$ similarly. Noting that $j^*A \to A$ is again the inclusion of an open subset, and using the fact that the inverse image part of any open geometric embedding is cartesian closed, we see that $(j/A)^*\colon Sh(X)/A \to Sh(U)/j^*A$ is cartesian closed for any $A$. Hence $j$ is locally connected.

The case of $Sh(X)$ for a topological space $X$ was an exercise (p.417) in SGA4:

The concept relative to other bases was introduced in the following paper:

The standard reference is section C3.3 of

Further references include

• Olivia Caramello, Syntactic Characterizations of Properties of Classifying Toposes , TAC 26 no.6 (2012) pp.176-193. (pdf)

• Jonathon Funk, The locally connected coclosure of a Grothendieck topos, JPAA 137 (1999) pp.17-27.

• Peter Johnstone, Remarks on Punctual Local Connectedness , TAC 25 no.3 (2011) pp.51-63. (pdf)

• Ieke Moerdijk, Continuous fibrations and inverse limits of toposes , Comp. Math. 58 (1986) pp.45-72. (pdf)

• Ieke Moerdijk, Gavin Wraith, Connected and locally connected toposes are path connected , Trans. AMS 295 (1986) pp.849-859. (pdf)