nLab Polchinski completeness hypothesis

Context

Physics

physics, mathematical physics, philosophy of physics

Surveys, textbooks and lecture notes


theory (physics), model (physics)

experiment, measurement, computable physics

Differential cohomology

Contents

Idea

In physics/quantum field theory, the completeness hypothesis due to Polchinski 2004 is a statement about the applicability of (Dirac charge quantization): which says that (p. 3):

“…for every gauge field there will exist electric and magnetic sources…”

or in more detail:

“In any fully unified theory, for every gauge field there will exist electric and magnetic sources with the minimum relative Dirac quantum n=1n = 1”,

where the minimality clause is further explained to mean that:

“more precisely, the lattice of electric and magnetic charges is maximal.”

The term “completeness hypothesis” for this statement appears in Banks & Seiberg 2011 p. 1 & §4.3, now counted as a “swampland conjecture” (cf. Harlow & Ooguri 2021 p. 1). A precise formulation appears in SS 2025 Rem. 4.5 (v).

References

The original article:

Followup consideration in the context of the no-global-symmetries conjecture:

Identification with minimality of the classifying space‘s Sullivan model which encodes the Bianchi identities in the differential nonabelian cohomology of higher gauge fields:

Last revised on November 7, 2026 at 19:12:26. See the history of this page for a list of all contributions to it.