nLab D=11 N=1 supergravity

Redirected from "D=11 supergravity".

Context

Gravity

gravity, supergravity

Formalism

Definition

Spacetime configurations

Properties

Spacetimes

Quantum theory

String theory

Physics

physics, mathematical physics, philosophy of physics

Surveys, textbooks and lecture notes


theory (physics), model (physics)

experiment, measurement, computable physics

Contents

Idea

N=1N=1 supergravity in d=11d = 11, hence on an 11-manifold.

for the moment see the respective section at D'Auria-Fre formulation of supergravity

11d-SuGra from Super C-Field Flux Quantization

We discuss (Thm. below, following GSS24, §3) how the equations of motion of D=11 supergravity — on an 11|3211\vert\mathbf{32}-dimensional super-torsion-free super spacetime XX with super vielbein (e,ψ)(e,\psi) (the graviton/gravitino-fields) — follow from just the requirement that the duality-symmetric super-C-field flux densities (G 4 s,G 7 s)∈Ω dR 4(X)×Ω dR 7(X)(G_4^s, G_7^s) \,\in\, \Omega^4_{dR}(X) \times \Omega^7_{dR}(X):

  1. satisfy their Bianchi identities

    (1)dG 4 s=0 dG 7 s=12G 4 sG 4 s \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \, G_4^s \;=\; 0 \\ \mathrm{d} \, G_7^s \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} G_4^s \, G_4^s \end{array}
  2. are on any super-chart U↪XU \hookrightarrow X of the locally supersymmetric form

    (2)G 4 s=14!(G 4) a 1⋯a 4e a 1⋯e a 4−12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)e a 1e a 2 G 7 s=17!(G 7) a 1⋯a 7e a 1⋯e a 7−15!(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5ψ)e a 1⋯e a 5. \begin{array}{l} G_4^s \;=\; \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} \,-\, \tfrac{1}{2} \big(\overline{\psi}\Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi\big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \\ G_7^s \;=\; \tfrac{1}{7!} (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_7} e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_7} \,-\, \tfrac{1}{5!} \big(\overline{\psi}\Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} \psi\big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_5} \mathrlap{\,.} \end{array}

Up to some mild (but suggestive, see below) re-arrangement, the computation is essentially that indicated in CDF91, §III.8.5 (where some of the easy checks are indicated) which in turn is a mild reformulation of the original claim in Cremmer & Ferrara 1980 and Brink & Howe 1980 (where less details were given). A full proof is laid out in GSS24, §3, whose notation we follow here.

The following may be understood as an exposition of this result, which seems to stand out as the only account that is (i) fully first-order and (ii) duality-symmetric (in that G 7G_7 enters the EoMs as an independent field, whose Hodge duality to G 4G_4 is imposed by the Bianchi identity for G 7 sG_7^s, remarkably).

Notice that the discussion in CDF91, §III.8 amplifies the superspace-rheonomy principle as a constraint that makes the Bianchi identities on (in our paraphrase) a supergravity Lie 6-algebra-valued higher vielbein be equivalent to the equations of motion of D=11 SuGra. But we may observe that the only rheonomic constraint necessary is that (2) on the C-field flux density — and this is the one not strictly given by rules in CDF91, p. 874, cf. around CDF91, (III.8.41) —; while the remaining rheonomy condition on the gravitino field strength ρ\rho is implied (Lem. below), and the all-important torsion constraint (3) (which is also outside the rules of rheonomy constraints, cf. CDF91, (III.8.33)) is naturally regarded as part of the definition of a super-spacetime in the first place (Def. below).

In thus recasting the formulation of the theorem somewhat, we also:

  1. re-define the super-flux densities as above (2), highlighting that it is (only) in this combination that the algebraic form of the expected Bianchi identity (1) extends to superspace;

  2. disregard the gauge potentials C 3C_3 and C 6C_6, whose role in CDF91, §III.8.2-4 is really just to motivate the form of the Bianchi identities equivalent to (1), but whose global nature is more subtle than acknowledged there, while being irrelevant for just the equations of motion.

Indeed, the point is that, in consequence of our second item above, the following formulation shows that one may apply flux quantization of the supergravity C-field on superspace in formally the same way as bosonically (for instance in Cohomotopy as per Hypothesis H, or in any other nonabelian cohomology theory whose classifying space has the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-Whitehead L ∞ L_\infty -algebra of the 4-sphere), and in fact that the ability to do so implies the EoMs of 11d SuGra. Any such choice of flux quantization is then what defines, conversely, the gauge potentials, globally. Moreover, by the fact brought out here, that the super-flux Bianchi identity already implies the full equations of motion, this flux quantization is thereby seen to be compatible with the equations of motion on all of super spacetime.


For the present formulation, we find it suggestive to regard the all-important torsion constraint (3) as part of the definition of the super-gravity field itself (since it ties the auxiliary spin-connection to the super-vielbein field which embodies the actual super-metric structure):

Definition

(super-spacetime)
For

by a super-spacetime of super-dimension D|ND\vert \mathbf{N} we here mean:

  1. a supermanifold

  2. which admits an open cover by super-Minkowski supermanifolds ℝ 1,D−1|N\mathbb{R}^{1,D-1\vert \mathbf{N}},

  3. equipped with a super Cartan connection with respect to the canonical subgroup inclusion Spin(1,D−1)↪Iso(ℝ 1,D−1|N)Spin(1,D-1) \hookrightarrow Iso(\mathbb{R}^{1,D-1\vert\mathbf{N}}) of the spin group into the super Poincaré group, namely:

    1. equipped with a super-vielbein (e,ψ)(e, \psi), hence on each super-chart U↪XU \hookrightarrow X

      ((e a) a=0 D=1,(ψ α) α=1 N)∈Ω dR 1(U;ℝ 1,D−1|N) \big( (e^a)_{a=0}^{D=1} ,\, (\psi^\alpha)_{\alpha=1}^N \big) \;\in\; \Omega^1_{dR}\big( U ;\, \mathbb{R}^{1,D-1\vert \mathbf{N}} \big)

      such that at every point x∈X⇝x \in \overset{\rightsquigarrow}{X} the induced map on tangent spaces is an isomorphism

      (e,ψ) x:T xX⟶∼ℝ 1,10|N. (e,\psi)_x \;\colon\; T_x X \overset{\sim}{\longrightarrow} \mathbb{R}^{1,10\vert \mathbf{N}} \,.
    2. and with a spin-connection ω\omega (…),

  4. such that the super-torsion vanishes, in that on each chart:

    (3)de a−ω a be b=(ψ¯Γ aψ), \mathrm{d} \, e^a - \omega^a{}_b \, e^b \;=\; \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^a\, \psi \big) \,,

    where Γ (−):ℝ 1,D−1⟶End ℝ(N)\Gamma^{(-)} \,\colon\, \mathbb{R}^{1,D-1} \longrightarrow End_{\mathbb{R}}(\mathbf{N}) is a representation of Pin + ( 1 , 10 ) Pin^+(1,10) , hence

    Γ aΓ b+Γ bΓ a=+2diag(−,+,+,⋯,+) ab. \Gamma_{a} \Gamma_b + \Gamma_{b} \Gamma_a \;=\; + 2\, diag(-, +, +, \cdots, +)_{a b} \,.

Definition

(the gravitational field strength)
Given a super-spacetime (Def. ), we say that (super chart-wise):

  1. its super-torsion is:

    T a≔de a−ω a be b−(ψ¯Γ aψ) T^a \;\coloneqq\; \mathrm{d}\, e^a \,-\, \omega^a{}_b \, e^b \,-\, \big( \overline{\psi}\Gamma^a\psi \big)
  2. its gravitino field strength is

    ρ≔dψ+14ω abΓ abψ, \rho \;\coloneqq\; \mathrm{d}\, \psi + \tfrac{1}{4} \omega_{a b}\Gamma^{a b}\psi \,,
  3. its curvature is

    R a b≔dω a b−ω a cω c b. R^{a}{}_b \;\coloneqq\; \mathrm{d}\, \omega^{a}{}_b \,-\, \omega^a{}_c \, \omega^c{}_b \,.

Lemma

(super-gravitational Bianchi identities)
By exterior calculus the gravitational field strength tensors (Def. ) satisfy the following identities:

(4)dR a b = ω a a′R a′ b−R a b′ω b′ b dT a = −R a be b+2(ψ¯Γ aρ) dρ = 14R abΓ abψ \begin{array}{ccl} \mathrm{d} \, R^{a}{}_b &=& \omega^a{}_{a'} \, R^{a'}{}_b - R^{a}{}_{b'} \, \omega^{b'}{}_{b} \\ \mathrm{d} \, T^a &=& - R^{a}{}_b \ e^b + 2 \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^a\, \rho \big) \\ \mathrm{d} \, \rho &=& \tfrac{1}{4} R^{a b} \Gamma_{a b} \psi \end{array}

Remark

(role of the gravitational Bianchi identities)
Notice that the equations (4) are not conditions but identities satisfied by any super-spacetime (in the sense of Def. , hence even such that T a=0T^a = 0.) But conversely this means that when constructing a super-spacetime (say subject to further contraints, such as Bianchi identities for flux densities), the equations (4) are a necessary condition to be satisfied by any candidate super-vielbein-field, and as such they may play the role of equations of motion for the super-gravitational field, as we will see.


Write now 32∈Rep ℝ(Spin(1,10))\mathbf{32} \in Rep_{\mathbb{R}}\big(Spin(1,10)\big) for the unique non-trivial irreducible real Spin ( 1 , 10 ) Spin(1,10) -representation.

Theorem

(11d SuGra EoM from super-flux Bianchi identity) Given

  1. (super-gravity field:) an 11|3211\vert\mathbf{32}-dimensional super-spacetime XX (Def. ),

  2. (super-C-field flux densities:) (G 4 s,G 7 s)(G^s_4,\, G^s_7) as in (2)

then the super-flux Bianchi identity (1) (the super-higher Maxwell equation for the C-field)

dG 4 s=0 dG 7 s=12G 4 sG 4 s \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \, G_4^s \;=\; 0 \\ \mathrm{d} \, G_7^s \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} G_4^s \, G_4^s \end{array}

is equivalent to the joint solution by (e,ψ,ω,G 4 s,G 7 s)\big(e, \psi, \omega, G_4^s,\, G_7^s\big) of the equations of motion of D=11 supergravity.

This is, in some paraphrase, the result of CDF91, §III.8.5, We indicate the proof broken up in the following Lemmas , , and .

In all of the following lemmas one expands the Bianchi identoties in their super-vielbein form components.

Remark

(Normalization conventions)
Our choice of prefactors and normalization follows CDF91 except for the following changes:

  • our Clifford generators absorb a factor of i \mathrm{i} : Γ a=iΓ a DF\;\;\;\Gamma_a \;=\; \mathrm{i}\, \Gamma_a^{^{DF}}

  • our gravitinos absorb a factor of 2\sqrt{2}: ψ=2ψ DF\;\;\;\psi \;=\; \sqrt{2}\psi^{^{DF}}

  • our 4-flux density absorbs a combinatorial factor of 1/21/2: G 4=12R □\;\;\;G_4 = \tfrac{1}{2} R^{\Box}

  • our 7-flux density absorbs a combinatoiral factor of 1/5!1/5!: G 7=15!R ⊗\;\;\;G_7 = \tfrac{1}{5!} R^{\otimes}

Here:

  • The first rescaling reflects that Γ DF\Gamma^{{}^{\mathrm{DF}}} is not actually a Majorana representation of Pin +(1,10)\mathrm{Pin}^+(1,10), but iΓ DF\mathrm{i}\Gamma^{{}^{\mathrm{DF}}} is.

    This rescaling removes all occurrences of imaginary units in the Bianchi identities, as it should be for algebra over the real numbers with real fermion representations.

  • The second rescaling has the effect that de a=(ψ¯Γ aψ)+⋯\mathrm{d} e^a = \big(\overline{\psi} \Gamma^a \psi\big) + \cdots instead of de a=12(ψ¯Γ aψ)+⋯\mathrm{d}\, e^a = \tfrac{1}{2} \big(\overline{\psi} \Gamma^a \psi\big) + \cdots.

Lemma

The Bianchi identity for G 4 sG^s_4 (1) is equivalent to

  1. the closure of the ordinary 4-flux density G 4G_4

  2. the following dependence of ρ\rho on G 4G_4

shown in any super-chart:

(5)dG 4 s=0 ⇔{(∇ a(G 4) a 1⋯a 4)e ae a 1⋯e a 4=0 ρ=ρ abe ae b+(1613!(G 4) ab 1b 2b 3Γ ab 1b 2b 3−11214!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4Γ ab 1⋯b 4)⏟H aψe a (14!ψ α∇ α(G 4) a 1⋯a 4+(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ρ a 3a 4))e a 1⋯e a 4=0. \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d}\, G^s_4 \;=\; 0 \\ \;\Leftrightarrow\; \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \big( \nabla_{a} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \big) e^{a} \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} \;=\; 0 \\ \rho \;=\; \rho_{a b} \, e^{a} \, e^b \,+\, \underset{ H_a }{ \underbrace{ \Big( \tfrac{1}{6} \, \tfrac{1}{3!} (G_4)_{a b_1 b_2 b_3} \,\Gamma^{a b_1 b_2 b_3}\, \, - \tfrac{1}{12} \, \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{b_1 \cdots b_4} \,\Gamma^{a b_1 \cdots b_4}\, \Big) } } \psi \, e^a \\ \Big( \tfrac{1}{4!} \psi^\alpha \nabla_\alpha (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \;+\; \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \rho_{a_3 a_4} \big) \Big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} \;=\; 0 \,. \end{array} \right. \end{array}

This is essentially the claim in CDF91 (III.8.44-49 & 60b); full proof is given in GSS24, Lem. 3.2.
Proof

The general expansion of ρ\rho in the super-vielbein basis is of the form

ρ:=ρ abe ae b+H aψe a+ψ¯κψ⏟=0, \rho \;:=\; \rho_{a b} \, e^a\, e^b + H_a \psi \, e^a + \underset{ = 0 }{ \underbrace{ \overline{\psi} \,\kappa\, \psi } } \,,

where the last term is taken to vanish.l (…).

Therefore, the Bianchi identity has the following components,

(6)d(14!(G 4) a 1⋯a 4e a 1⋯e a 4−12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)e a 1e a 2)=0 ⇔{(∇ a(G 4) a 1⋯a 4)e ae a 1⋯e a 4=0 (14!ψ α(∇ α(G 4) a 1⋯a 4)+(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ρ a 3a 4))e a 1⋯e a 4=0 13!(G 4) ab 1b 2b 3(ψ¯Γ aψ)e b 1b 2b 3+(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2H bψ)e a 1e a 2e b=0, \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \Big( \, \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} - \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi \big) \, e^{a_1}\, e^{a_2} \Big) \;=\; 0 \\ \;\Leftrightarrow\; \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \big( \nabla_{a} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \big) e^{a}\, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} \;=\; 0 \\ \Big( \tfrac{1}{4!} \psi^\alpha \big( \nabla_\alpha (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \big) \;+\; \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \rho_{a_3 a_4} \big) \Big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} \;=\; 0 \\ \tfrac{1}{3!} (G_4)_{a b_1 b_2 b_3} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^a\, \psi \big) \, e^{b_1 b_2 b_3} + \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 a_2}\, H_b \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^b \;=\; 0 \,, \end{array} \right. \end{array}

where we used that the quartic spinorial component vanishes identically, due to a Fierz identity (here):

−12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)(ψ¯Γ a 1ψ)e a 2=0. - \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi \big) \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma^{a_1} \psi \big) e^{a_2} \;=\; 0 \,.

To solve the second line in (6) for H aH_a (this is CDF91 (III.8.43-49)) we expand H aH_a in the Clifford algebra (according to this Prop.), observing that for Γ a 1a 2H a 3\Gamma_{a_1 a_2} H_{a_3} to be a linear combination of the Γ a\Gamma_a the matrix H aH_a needs to have a Γ a 1\Gamma_{a_1}-summand or a Γ a 1a 2a 3\Gamma_{a_1 a_2 a_3}-summand. The former does not admit a Spin-equivariant linear combination with coefficients (G 4) a 1⋯a 4(G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4}, hence it must be the latter. But then we may also need a component Γ a 1⋯a 5\Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} in order to absorb the skew-symmetric product in Γ a 1a 2H a\Gamma_{a_1 a_2} H_a. Hence H aH_a must be of this form:

(7)H a=const 113!(G 4) ab 1b 2b 3Γ b 1b 2b 3+const 214!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4Γ ab 1⋯b 4. H_a \;=\; \mathrm{const}_1 \, \tfrac{1}{3!} (G_4)_{a b_1 b_2 b_3} \Gamma^{b_1 b_2 b_3} + \mathrm{const}_2 \, \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \Gamma_{a b_1 \cdots b_4} \,.

With this, we compute:

(8)(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2H a 3ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3 =const 113!(G 4) a 3b 1b 2b 3(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2Γ b 1b 2b 3ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3 +const 214!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2Γ a 3b 1⋯b 4ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3 =1const 113!(G 4) a 3b 1b 2b 3(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2 b 1b 2b 3ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3 +6const 113!(G 4) b 3a 1a 2a 3(ψ¯Γ b 3ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3 +8const 214!(G 4) b 1⋯b 3a 3(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2 b 1⋯b 3ψ)e a 1e a 2e a 3. \begin{array}{ll} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} H_{a_3} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} & =\; \mathrm{const}_1 \, \tfrac{1}{3!} (G_4)_{a_3 b_1 b_2 b_3} \, \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \Gamma^{b_1 b_2 b_3} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} \\ & \;\;\;+\, \mathrm{const}_2 \, \tfrac{1}{4!} \, (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \, \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \Gamma_{a_3 b_1 \cdots b_4} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} \\ & \;=\; 1 \, \mathrm{const}_1 \, \tfrac{1}{3!} \, (G_4)_{a_3 b_1 b_2 b_3} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 a_2}{}^{b_1 b_ 2 b_3}\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} \\ & \;\;\;+\, 6 \, \mathrm{const}_1 \, \tfrac{1}{3!} \, (G_4)_{b_3 a_1 a_2 a_3} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^{b_3}\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} \\ & \;\;\;+\, 8 \, \mathrm{const}_2 \, \tfrac{1}{4!} \, (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_3 a_3} \, \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma^{a_1 a_2}{}_{b_1 \cdots b_3} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \, e^{a_3} \,. \end{array}

Here the multiplicities of the nonvanishing Clifford-contractions arise via this Lemma:

1=0!(20)(30) 6=2!(22)(32) 8=1!(21)(41), \begin{array}{l} 1 \;=\; 0! \Big( {2 \atop 0} \Big) \Big( {3 \atop 0} \Big) \\ 6 \;=\; 2! \Big( {2 \atop 2} \Big) \Big( {3 \atop 2} \Big) \\ 8 \;=\; 1! \Big( {2 \atop 1} \Big) \Big( {4 \atop 1} \Big) \,, \end{array}

and all remaining contractions vanish inside the spinor pairing by this lemma.

Now using (8) in (6) yields:

const 1=−1/6, const 2=−4!/3!const 1/8=+1/12, \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{const}_1 = -1/6 \,, \\ \mathrm{const}_2 = - 4!/3! \, \mathrm{const}_1 / 8 = + 1/12 \,, \end{array}

as claimed.

Lemma

Given the Bianchi identity for G 4 sG^s_4 (5), then the Bianchi identity for G 7 sG^s_7 (1) is equivalent to

  1. the Bianchi identity for the ordinary flux density G 7G_7

  2. its Hodge duality to G 4G_4

  3. another condition on the gravitino field strength

(9)dG 7 s=12G 4 sG 4 s ⇔{(∇ a 117!(G 7) a 2⋯a 8)e a 1⋯e a 8=12(14!(G 4) a 1⋯a 414!(G 4) a 5⋯a 8)e a 1⋯e a 8 (G 7) a 1⋯a 7=14!ϵ a 1⋯a bb 1⋯b 4(G 4) b 1⋯b 4 (17!ψ α∇ α(G 7) a 1⋯a 7ψ α+25!(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5ρ a 6a 7))e a 1⋯e a 7=0 \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \, G^s_7 \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} G^s_4 \, G^s_4 \\ \;\Leftrightarrow\; \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \big( \nabla_{a_1} \tfrac{1}{7!} (G_7)_{a_2 \cdots a_8} \big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_8} \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \, \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_5 \cdots a_8} \big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_8} \\ (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_7} \;=\; \tfrac{1}{4!} \epsilon_{a_1 \cdots a_b b_1 \cdots b_4} (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \\ \Big( \tfrac{1}{7!} \psi^\alpha \nabla_\alpha (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_7} \psi^\alpha \;+\; \frac{2}{5!} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} \rho_{a_6 a_7} \big) \Big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_7} \;=\; 0 \end{array} \right. \end{array}

This is essentially CDF91, (III.8.50-53).
Proof

The components of the Bianchi identity are

dG 4 s=0 ⇒{d(17!(G 7) a 1⋯a 7e a 1⋯e a 7−15!(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5ψ)e a 1⋯e a 5) =12(14!(G 4) a 1⋯a 4e a 1⋯e a 4−12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ))(14!(G 4) a 1⋯a 4e a 1⋯e a 4−12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)) ⇔{(∇ a 117!(G 7) a 2⋯a 8=1214!(G 4) a 1⋯a 414!(G 4) a 5⋯a 8)e a 1⋯e a 8 (17!ψ α∇ α(G 7) a 1⋯a 7+25!(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5ρ a 6a 7))e a 1⋯e a 7=0 16!(G 7) a 1⋯a 6b(ψ¯Γ bψ)e a 1⋯e a 6 +21215!14!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5Γ ab 1⋯b 4ψ)e ae a 1⋯e a 5 −2615!13!(G 4) ab 1b 2b 3(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5Γ b 1b 2b 3ψ)e ae a 1⋯e a 5 −(12(ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)e a 1e a 2)14!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4e b 1⋯e b 4=0,}⇔(G 7) a 1⋯a 6b=14!ϵ a 1⋯a 6bb 1⋯b 4(G 4) b 1⋯b 4 \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \, G_4^s \;=\; 0 \\ \Rightarrow \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d} \Big( \tfrac{1}{7!} (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_7} \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_7} - \tfrac{1}{5!} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_5} \Big) \\ \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} \Big( \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} - \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi \big) \Big) \Big( \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_4} - \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi \big) \Big) \\ \;\Leftrightarrow\; \left\{ \begin{array}{l} \Big( \nabla_{a_1} \tfrac{1}{7!} (G_7)_{a_2 \cdots a_8} \;=\; \;\tfrac{1}{2}\; \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_1 \cdots a_4} \, \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{a_5 \cdots a_8} \Big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_8} \\ \Big( \tfrac{1}{7!} \psi^\alpha \nabla_\alpha (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_7} + \frac{2}{5!} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} \rho_{a_6 a_7} \big) \Big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_7} \;=\; 0 \\ \left. \begin{array}{l} \tfrac{1}{6!} (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_6 b} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^b\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_6} \\ \;\;\;+\, \tfrac{2}{12} \, \tfrac{1}{5!} \, \tfrac{1}{4!} \, (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \big( \overline{\psi} \, \Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5} \, \Gamma_{a b_1 \cdots b_4}\, \psi \big) e^a \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_5} \\ \;\;-\; \tfrac{2}{6} \tfrac{1}{5!} \tfrac{1}{3!} (G_4)_{a b_1 b_2 b_3} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5}\, \Gamma^{b_1 b_2 b_3} \psi \big) e^{a} \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_5} \\ \;\;\;-\, \Big( \tfrac{1}{2} \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi \big) e^{a_1} \, e^{a_2} \Big) \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)_{b_1 \cdots b_4} \, e^{b_1} \cdots e^{b_4} \;\;=\;\; 0 \,, \end{array} \right\} \Leftrightarrow (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_6 b} \;=\; \tfrac{1}{4!} \epsilon_{a_1 \cdots a_6 b b_1 \cdots b_4} (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \end{array} \right. \end{array} \right. \end{array}

where:

(i) in the quadratic spinorial component we inserted the expression for ρ\rho from (5), then contracted Γ\Gamma-factors using again this Lemma, and finally observed that of the three spinorial quadratic forms (see there) the coefficients of (ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)\big(\overline{\psi}\Gamma_{a_1 a_2} \psi\big) and of (ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 6ψ)\big(\overline{\psi}\Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_6} \psi\big) vanish identically, by a remarkable cancellation of combinatorial prefactors:

  • (−21215!14!4!(54)(44)+2615!13!3!(53)(33)−1214!)⏟=0(G 4) a 2⋯a 5(ψ¯Γ aa 1ψ)e ae a 1⋯e a 6\underset{= 0 }{\underbrace{\bigg(- \frac{2}{12} \frac{1}{5!} \frac{1}{4!} 4! \Big( { 5 \atop 4 } \Big) \Big( { 4 \atop 4 } \Big) \;+\; \frac{2}{6} \frac{1}{5!} \frac{1}{3!} 3! \Big( { 5 \atop 3 } \Big) \Big( { 3 \atop 3 } \Big) \;-\; \frac{1}{2} \frac{1}{4!} \bigg) } } \; (G_4)_{a_2 \cdots a_5} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a a_1}\, \psi \big) e^{a} \, e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_6} \;\;\; (check)

  • (21215!14!2(52)(42)−2615!13!1(51)(31))⏟=0(G 4) a 1a 2b 1b 2(ψ¯Γ a 3⋯a 6 b 1b 2ψ)e a 1⋯e a 6\underset{ = 0 }{ \underbrace{ \bigg( \frac{2}{12} \frac{1}{5!} \frac{1}{4!} 2 \Big( { 5 \atop 2 } \Big) \Big( { 4 \atop 2 } \Big) \;-\; \frac{2}{6} \frac{1}{5!} \frac{1}{3!} 1 \Big( { 5 \atop 1 } \Big) \Big( { 3 \atop 1 } \Big) \bigg) } } \; (G_4)_{a_1 a_2 b_1 b_2} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_3 \cdots a_6}{}^{b_1 b_2}\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} \cdots e^{a_6} \;\;\; (check)

(ii) the quartic spinorial component holds identitically, due to the Fierz identity here:

−14!(ψ¯Γ a 1⋯a 5ψ)(ψ¯Γ a 1)e a 2⋯e a 5=18((ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)e a 1e a 2)((ψ¯Γ a 1a 2ψ)e a 1e a 2). -\tfrac{1}{4!} \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 \cdots a_5}\, \psi \big) \big( \overline{\psi} \Gamma^{a_1} \big) e^{a_2} \cdots e^{a_5} \;=\; \tfrac{1}{8} \Big( \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 a_2}\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} e^{a_2} \Big) \Big( \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma_{a_1 a_2}\, \psi \big) e^{a_1} e^{a_2} \Big) \,.

Therefore the only spinorial component of the Bianchi identity which is not automatically satisfied is (with Γ 012⋯=ϵ 012⋯\Gamma_{0 1 2 \cdots} = \epsilon_{0 1 2 \cdots}, see there) the vanishing of

16!((G 7) a 1⋯a 6b−14!(G 4) b 1⋯b 4ϵ b 1⋯b 4a 1⋯a 6b)(ψ¯Γ bψ), \tfrac{1}{6!} \Big( (G_7)_{a_1 \cdots a_6 b} - \tfrac{1}{4!} (G_4)^{b_1 \cdots b_4} \epsilon_{b_1 \cdots b_4 a_1 \cdots a_6 b} \Big) \big( \overline{\psi} \,\Gamma^b\, \psi \big) \,,

which is manifestly the claimed Hodge duality relation.

Lemma

Given the Bianchi identities for G 4 sG_4^s (5) and G 7 sG_7^s (9), the supergravity fields satisfy their Einstein equations with source the energy momentum tensor of the C-field:

(10)dG 4 s=0,dG 7 s=12G 4 sG 4 2 ⇒{R bm am−12δ b aR mn mn=−112((G 4) ac 1⋯c 3(G 4) bc 1⋯c 3−18(G 4) c 1⋯c 4(G 4) c 1⋯c 4δ b a(Einstein equation) Γ ba 1a 2ρ a 1a 2=0(Rarita-Schwinger equation) \begin{array}{l} \mathrm{d}\, G_4^s \;=\;0 \,, \;\;\; \mathrm{d}\, G_7^s \;=\; \tfrac{1}{2} G_4^s \, G_4^2 \\ \;\Rightarrow\; \left\{ \begin{array}{l} R^{a m}_{b m} - \tfrac{1}{2} \delta^a_b\, R^{m n}_{m n} \;=\; - \tfrac{1}{12} \Big( \, (G_4)^a{c_1 \cdots c_3} (G_4)_{b c_1 \cdots c_3} - \tfrac{1}{8} (G_4)^{c_1 \cdots c_4} (G_4)_{c_1 \cdots c_4} \delta^a_b \;\;\;\; ({\color{darkblue}\text{Einstein equation}}) \\ \Gamma^{b a_1 a_2} \rho_{a_1 a_2} \;=\; 0 \;\;\;\; ({\color{darkblue}\text{Rarita-Schwinger equation}}) \end{array} \right. \end{array}

Cf. e.g. CDF91, (III.8.54-60); full details are given in GSS24, Lem. 3.8.

In conclusion, the above lemmas give Thm. .

The action functional

(…)

Kinetic terms

(…)

The higher Chern-Simons term

Let X 11X^{11} be spin and put λ=12p 1(TX)\lambda=\tfrac12 p_1(TX). In the convention of I8 the gravitational characteristic class is

I 8(TX)=p 2(TX)−λ 248. I_8(TX)=\frac{p_2(TX)-\lambda^2}{48}.

Write I 8(R)I_8(R) for its Chern–Weil representative. In membrane charge units put g 4=G 4/(2π)g_4=G_4/(2\pi) and locally g 4=dc 3g_4=\mathrm{d}c_3. With the overall sign of Witten, (4.4), the local expression for the topological part of the action is

S top2π=∫ X 11(−16c 3∧g 4∧g 4+c 3∧I 8(R)). \frac{S_{\mathrm{top}}}{2\pi} =\int_{X^{11}}\left( -\frac16\,c_3\wedge g_4\wedge g_4 +c_3\wedge I_8(R) \right).

This formula applies directly when the potential is globally a form. For a topologically nontrivial supergravity C-field, defining the phase involves shifted C-field flux quantization and the global definition of the fermion phase. (Witten, §§2, 4–5, Diaconescu, Freed & Moore)

What is integral? Consider a closed spin eight-manifold YY and evaluate the characteristic classes of TYTY. The index of its spin Dirac operator gives

indD Y=∫ Y7λ 2−p 21440,∫ YI 8=18∫ Yλ 2−30indD Y. \operatorname{ind}D_Y=\int_Y\frac{7\lambda^2-p_2}{1440}, \qquad \int_Y I_8=\frac18\int_Y\lambda^2-30\,\operatorname{ind}D_Y .

The curvature contribution alone can be fractional. On a smooth sextic fourfold in ℂℙ 5\mathbb{CP}^5, for instance, ∫ YI 8=χ(Y)/24=2610/24=435/4\int_Y I_8=\chi(Y)/24=2610/24=435/4. In the present sign convention ∫ YI 8\int_Y I_8 is the number called JJ by Witten. (Witten, (3.1)–(3.2), Sethi, Vafa & Witten, §2.1)

The membrane tadpole also includes the flux. Write [g 4]=a+λ/2[g_4]=a+\lambda/2 in real cohomology, with aa the image of an integral class. Since λbmod2\lambda\bmod 2 is the fourth Wu class of YY, one has ∫ Ya 2≡∫ Yaλ(mod2)\int_Y a^2\equiv\int_Y a\lambda\pmod 2. Consequently

∫ Y(I 8(R)−12g 4∧g 4)=−30indD Y−12∫ Ya(a+λ)∈ℤ. \int_Y\left( I_8(R)-\frac{1}{2} g_4\wedge g_4 \right) = -30\,indD_Y -\frac{1}{2}\int_Y a(a+\lambda) \;\in\;\mathbb{Z} \mathrlap{\,.}

In particular, when λ\lambda is divisible by two, zero flux is allowed by the shifted quantization law and the curvature contribution ∫ YI 8\int_Y I_8 is itself an integer. (Witten, (1.2) and (3.1)–(3.5))

The hidden deformation

There is in fact a hidden 1-parameter deformation of the Lagrangian of 11d sugra. Mathematically this was maybe first noticed in (D’Auria-Fre 82) around equation (4.25). This shows that there is a topological term which may be expressed as

∝∫ X 11G 4∧G 7 \propto \; \textstyle{\int}_{X_11} G_4 \wedge G_7

where G 4G_4 is the curvature 3-form of the supergravity C-field and G 7G_7 that of the magnetically dual C6-field. However, (D’Auria-Fre 82) consider only topologically trivial (trivial instanton sector) configurations of the supergravity C-field, and since on them this term is a total derivative, the authors “drop” it.

The term then re-appears in the literatur in (Bandos-Berkovits-Sorokin 97, equation (4.13)). And it seems that this is the same term later also redicovered around equation (4.2) in (Tsimpis 04).

(hm, check)

Properties

BPS states

The basic BPS states of 11d SuGra are

(e.g. EHKNT 07)

Higher curvature corrections to 11D supergravity

Eleven-dimensional supergravity is meant to describe the long-wavelength dynamics of the graviton, the three-form C 3C_3 and the gravitino of M-theory. The first local higher curvature correction visible in flat-space graviton scattering has eight derivatives. Two features of this correction are particularly well established. The four-graviton scattering amplitude fixes a quartic-curvature coupling, and cancellation of the gravitational anomaly of an M5-brane requires a coupling C 3∧I 8(R)C_3\wedge I_8(R) with a definite coefficient. What remains only partly known is the nonlinear supersymmetric interaction of all three fields on a general background. (Chester, Pufu & Yin, §1, Duff, Liu & Minasian, §3, Souères & Tsimpis, §§1, 4–5, Aggarwal et al., §§1, 5)

What is the expansion in the Planck length?

Consider a process of wavelength LL, or a weakly curved background of curvature radius LL. A Riemann tensor counts as two derivatives. An interaction ℓ p 6R 4\ell_p^6 R^4, where R 4R^4 stands for contractions of four Riemann tensors, therefore contributes at relative order (ℓ p/L) 6(\ell_p/L)^6 compared with the Einstein term. The low-energy limit is L≫ℓ pL\gg\ell_p, equivalently Eℓ p≪1E\ell_p\ll1 in units ℏ=c=1\hbar=c=1.

Uncompactified M-theory is expected to have “no dimensionless coupling constant”. One can set ℓ p\ell_p equal to one by choosing units and still perform experiments at different energies in those units. The numbers multiplying independent interactions are data of the theory, to be determined by matching. Restoring ℏ\hbar, with c=1c=1, gives ℓ p 9∝ℏG 11\ell_p^9\propto\hbar G_{11}, where G 11G_{11} is Newton’s constant. A correction proportional to ℓ p 6\ell_p^6 thus disappears in the classical limit at fixed G 11G_{11} and LL. A classical gravity theory with an independently specified length could contain the same curvature polynomial. (Chester, Pufu & Yin, §1 and footnote 9)

Compactification adds a scale. On a circle of radius R 11R_{11}, the ratio R 11/ℓ p=g s 2/3R_{11}/\ell_p=g_s^{2/3}, in the usual Planck-length convention, determines the string coupling constant of type IIA string theory. Varying this modulus varies the ten-dimensional coupling. (Witten, §2)

In what sense are the corrections quantum?

  • The ten-dimensional string calculation. The type IIA interaction B 2∧I 8(R)B_2\wedge I_8(R) occurs at genus one of the closed string. This is the origin of the name one-loop term for I 8 I_8 . At the same order α′ 3\alpha'^3 relative to the Einstein term, there is already a gravitational R 4R^4 interaction at genus zero. Powers of α′E 2\alpha' E^2 count derivatives, while each additional handle of the worldsheet costs a power of g s 2g_s^2. In the eleven-dimensional decompactification limit the IIA tree contribution is suppressed and the genus-one combination survives as a local 11D interaction. (Vafa & Witten, Gross & Witten, Souères & Tsimpis, (1.1)–(1.6))

  • The eleven-dimensional anomaly argument. Starting with the classical supergravity action, one can ask which extra interactions preserve local supersymmetry. That question alone leaves the overall coefficient of a first-order deformation free. Additional physical input comes from quantizing the chiral fields on a magnetic five-brane. Their gravitational anomaly requires anomaly inflow with a fixed normalization once the five-brane charge is specified. The quantum anomaly arises on the six-dimensional worldvolume. The corresponding inflow comes from varying the classical bulk coupling C 3∧I 8(R)C_3\wedge I_8(R) in the presence of the brane. The cubic bulk coupling also contributes to cancellation of the normal-bundle anomaly. On circle reduction, the component of C 3C_3 with one leg along the circle gives B 2B_2, reproducing the type IIA curvature coupling. (Duff, Liu & Minasian, §3, Hořava & Witten, discussion following (1.14), Freed et al.)

  • Loops of the eleven-dimensional bulk fields. With a momentum cutoff Λ\Lambda, the one-loop four-graviton amplitude of two-derivative supergravity contains a local term proportional to Λ 3t 8t 8R 4\Lambda^3 t_8t_8R^4. Its finite coefficient requires matching. On a circle this same 11D loop also gives a finite, radius-dependent term which reproduces the type IIA tree-level four-graviton coupling. Even in uncompactified space one can distinguish two orders experimentally in principle. In the amplitude divided by its tree value, the matched local R 4R^4 term is of order (Eℓ p) 6(E\ell_p)^6, while the nonanalytic threshold from a loop of massless supergravity fields is of order (Eℓ p) 9(E\ell_p)^9 at fixed scattering angle. Thus a power of ℓ p\ell_p labels an order in energy. Assigning a loop order requires specifying which fields are being quantized. (Green, Gutperle & Vanhove, (10)–(11), Chester, Pufu & Yin, (1.1)–(1.3))

There is a close analogue in 5-dimensional supergravity. Local supersymmetry gives a completion of A∧tr(R∧R)A\wedge\operatorname{tr}(R\wedge R). Integrating out charged massive fields gives a one-loop shift of its coefficient. One calculation determines how the interaction fits into supergravity. The other determines what a specified spectrum contributes to it. (Hanaki, Ohashi & Tachikawa, Bonetti, Grimm & Hohenegger)

What is known at eight derivatives?

  • Four gravitons. The first local correction to the four-graviton amplitude, divided by the tree amplitude of two-derivative supergravity, is ℓ 11 6stu/(3⋅2 7)\ell_{11}^6 s t u/(3\cdot 2^7) in the conventions of Chester, Pufu & Yin. Here s,t,us,t,u are the Mandelstam invariants and 2κ 11 2=(2π) 5ℓ 11 92\kappa_{11}^2=(2\pi)^5\ell_{11}^9 in their length convention. They recover this coefficient independently from a correlation function of the ABJM model. In a covariant action the purely gravitational terms can be represented, up to field redefinitions and overall normalization, by t 8t 8R 4−14!ϵ 11ϵ 11R 4t_8t_8R^4-\frac{1}{4!}\epsilon_{11}\epsilon_{11}R^4 in the conventions of Souères & Tsimpis. The four-graviton amplitude sees the t 8t 8t_8t_8 contraction. The leading expansion of the double-epsilon term is a total derivative, so it first contributes to graviton scattering at five points. (Chester, Pufu & Yin, (1.1)–(1.3) and footnote 9, Souères & Tsimpis, (1.5)–(1.6))

  • One three-form and four gravitons. The characteristic form in the inflow coupling is I 8(R)=148(p 2(R)−14p 1(R) 2)I_8(R)=\frac{1}{48}\big(p_2(R)-\frac14 p_1(R)^2\big) in the convention of I8. Its first vertex about flat space with vanishing background flux has five external fields. An eleven-dimensional superparticle calculation recovers its tensor structure and leaves the ultraviolet normalization to be supplied separately. (Anguelova, Grassi & Vanhove, §6.2, especially (6.27))

  • Flux and gravitini. Writing G 4G_4 for the four-form field strength, the bosonic four-point interactions include R 2(∇G 4) 2R^2(\nabla G_4)^2 and (∇G 4) 4(\nabla G_4)^4. Their circle reduction has been checked against type IIA string amplitudes, including amplitudes with Ramond–Ramond fields. Component supersymmetry has also fixed particular gravitino bilinears and constrained five-field terms of type R 3G 4 2R^3G_4^2. As Aggarwal et al. put it, “At higher points there are only partial results”. (Peeters, Plefka & Stern, Aggarwal et al., §§1, 3–5, Peeters, Vanhove & Westerberg, Hyakutake 2007, Hyakutake 2025)

An earlier power of ℓ p\ell_p occurs in the study of flux quantization. In the four-form deformation complex, the groups at orders ℓ p\ell_p and ℓ p 2\ell_p^2 vanish. At order ℓ p 3\ell_p^3 a class is represented by a shift of G 4G_4 proportional to ℓ p 3p 1(R)\ell_p^3 p_1(R). Locally one can absorb it by shifting C 3C_3 by a Lorentz Chern–Simons form. Globally it can change the flux quantization law. This accounts for the order ℓ p 3\ell_p^3 in Tsimpis’s analysis. The quartic-curvature interaction in graviton scattering occurs at order ℓ p 6\ell_p^6. (Tsimpis, (4.11)–(4.18), discussion at I 8I_8)

The anomaly-corrected seven-form Bianchi identity

Away from brane sources, the corrected bosonic C 3C_3 equation can be written to this order as

dG 4=0,dG 7+12G 4∧G 4=βI 8(R),β=O(ℓ p 6). \mathrm{d}G_4=0,\qquad \mathrm{d}G_7+\tfrac12 G_4\wedge G_4=\beta I_8(R), \qquad \beta=O(\ell_p^6).

Here the signs are those of the flux equation at I 8I_8, and β\beta includes the normalization of the fluxes. The gauge-invariant interactions involving G 4G_4 also contribute to this equation, through the corrected duality relation G 7=⋆G 4+O(ℓ p 6)G_7=\star G_4+O(\ell_p^6). A measurable consequence in a compactification on a smooth compact Calabi–Yau fourfold YY is that ∫ YI 8=χ(Y)/24\int_Y I_8=\chi(Y)/24 contributes to the membrane tadpole, constraining the net M2-brane charge and the four-form flux. (Souères & Tsimpis, (4.2)–(4.11), Sethi, Vafa & Witten, Becker & Becker, Witten, §3)

What remains to be constructed in superspace?

On superspace the curvature source has components with spinor indices. The flux and torsion Bianchi identities must hold in those components as well. First order here means first order in the coefficient β\beta. Even at first order the answer may depend nonlinearly on all the fields. There are three distinct questions.

  1. Does the anomaly coupling belong to a first-order superinvariant, and when is it unique? Howe & Tsimpis qualify their uniqueness argument with “Provided that this equation is consistent”. They also assume that the invariant begins at least quartically in the fields. Souères & Tsimpis give a sufficient condition for constructing it. Let X 0,8X_{0,8} denote the component with eight spinor indices of their anomaly superform X 8X_8, proportional to the superspace I 8I_8. If X 0,8X_{0,8} is exact for the algebraic differential τ\tau induced by the dimension-zero torsion, then G 4 (0)∧X 8G_4^{(0)}\wedge X_8 has a gauge-invariant superform primitive on undeformed on-shell superspace. The superform action principle then gives the invariant. Of three potentially obstructing Spin(1,10)\mathrm{Spin}(1,10) representations, they verify the cancellation of (04000)(04000) and (02004)(02004). Their paper leaves the (03002)(03002) cancellation unchecked. The quartic hypothesis matters for uniqueness. Assuming a perturbative solution of the Bianchi identities, they identify at least two independent eight-derivative invariants when lower powers of the fields are allowed. Only one has the required anomaly coupling. (Howe & Tsimpis, §5, following (56), Souères & Tsimpis, §§4.1–4.2, 5 and Appendix C)

  2. What are the actual corrected geometry and field equations? In the four-form formulation a first-order deformation is encoded by [G 0,4 (1)]∈H F 0,4(phys)[G^{(1)}_{0,4}]\in H_F^{0,4}(\mathrm{phys}). The subscripts count vector and spinor indices, and the coefficients are local expressions in the supergravity fields and their derivatives. Given a representative, the Bianchi identities relate it to the change in dimension-zero torsion and hence to the field equations. Cederwall, Gran, Nilsson & Tsimpis solve the geometric identities to first order for general torsion-deformation tensors. To obtain the explicit M-theory equations one must still construct the particular tensors selected by the anomaly and extract their component couplings, including the gravitino terms. (Howe & Tsimpis, §§4, 6, Cederwall, Gran, Nilsson & Tsimpis, §3 and Appendix B, details at I 8I_8)

  3. Does the deformation extend to higher orders? Already at second order the first-order change in the supersymmetry transformations acts on the first-order action. Its variation has to be cancelled by further local corrections. Each order presents a compatibility question. Independent invariants can also first occur at higher derivative orders, with coefficients requiring their own determination. The November 2026 nLab working materials describe a proposed continuation of the I 8I_8 deformation with its leading coefficient kept symbolic. Their overview reports a second-order result under stated hypotheses on the local complex, comparison maps, sources and extensions. It lists compatibility at arbitrary order as open. (Howe & Tsimpis, §7, Souères & Tsimpis, §4.3 and footnote 2)

What would the full tower determine?

Particular observables are known beyond eight derivatives. In the uncompactified four-graviton amplitude the coefficient of D 4R 4D^4R^4 vanishes and the coefficient of D 6R 4D^6R^4 is known. Here DD denotes a covariant derivative. Numerical conformal bootstrap calculations have also found evidence in ABJM data for the scaling expected from the unprotected D 8R 4D^8R^4 interaction. It is possible to know a later four-point coefficient while higher-point couplings at an earlier order are still being worked out. (Binder, Chester & Pufu, Green & Vanhove, Chester, Dempsey & Pufu, §3.2)

Knowing all local interactions of the massless multiplet, with their physical coefficients up to field redefinitions, would supply the vertices for low-energy scattering to every derivative order. Loops of the light fields then supply nonlocal contributions such as massless thresholds. On compactification one could calculate corrections to flux backgrounds and compare lower-dimensional couplings with string amplitudes, including the effects of Kaluza–Klein modes where appropriate. Even the leading correction changes the geometry of supersymmetric compactifications of special holonomy. (Chester, Pufu & Yin, §1, Green, Gutperle & Vanhove, Lü, Pope, Stelle & Townsend)

At energies of order 1/ℓ p1/\ell_p the derivative expansion loses its ordering by size. An ultraviolet completion would have to define observables there and account for the nonperturbative states and dynamics, including those of membranes and five-branes. The global quantization of the CC-field also requires information beyond a local Lagrangian density. The next question would be which microscopic dynamics reproduce the entire low-energy expansion and determine observables beyond it. The recovery of the R 4R^4 coefficient from ABJM gives a concrete example of how such a proposal can be tested. (Witten on flux quantization, Diaconescu, Freed & Moore, Banks et al. on matrix theory, Chester, Pufu & Yin)

See the references by method and application. Applications to inflation are discussed at Starobinsky model of cosmic inflation.

Relation to 5D supergravity

Structural similarity between D=11 and minimal D=5 supergravity
(cf. Mizoguchi & Ohta 1998; Fujii, Kemmoku & Mizoguchi 1999, 2000)

bulk spacetime dimensionD=11D=11D=5D = 5
bulk (higher) gauge fieldC-fieldMCS field
electric braneprobe M2-brane
black M2-brane
?0-brane
black hole in 5D
magnetic braneprobe M5-brane
black M5-brane
L1-brane
black string
near horizon geometriesel: AdS 4×S 7AdS_4 \times S^7
mg: AdS 7×S 4AdS_7 \times S^4
el: AdS 2×S 3AdS_2 \times S^3
mg: AdS 3×S 2AdS_3 \times S^2
bulk magnetic flux densityG 4G_4F 2F_2
bulk electric flux densityG 7=⋆ 11G 4G_7 = \star_{11} G_4F 3=⋆ 5F 2F_3 = \star_5 F_2
chiral flux on mg braneH 3H_3H 1H_1
Bianchi identitiesdG 4 =0 dG 7 =12G 4∧G 4 dH 3 =ϕ *G 4\begin{aligned}\mathrm{d} G_4 & = 0 \\ \mathrm{d} G_7 & = \tfrac{1}{2} G_4 \wedge G_4 \\ \mathrm{d} H_3 & = \phi^\ast G_4\end{aligned}dF 2 =0 dF 3 =12F 2∧F 2 dH 1 =ϕ *F 2\begin{aligned}\mathrm{d} F_2 & = 0 \\ \mathrm{d} F_3 & = \tfrac{1}{2} F_2 \wedge F_2 \\ \mathrm{d} H_1 & = \phi^\ast F_2 \end{aligned}
proper flux quantization
minimally classified by
quaternionic Hopf fibration
S 7⟶S 4S^7 \longrightarrow S^4
complex Hopf fibration
S 3⟶S 2S^3 \longrightarrow S^2

Table of branes appearing in supergravity/string theory (for classification see at brane scan).

branein supergravitycharged under gauge fieldhas worldvolume theory
black branesupergravityhigher gauge fieldSCFT
D-branetype IIRR-fieldsuper Yang-Mills theory
(D=2n)(D = 2n)type IIA\,\,
D(-2)-brane\,\,
D0-brane\,\,BFSS matrix model
D2-brane\,\,\,
D4-brane\,\,D=5 super Yang-Mills theory with Khovanov homology observables
D6-brane\,\,D=7 super Yang-Mills theory
D8-brane\,\,
(D=2n+1)(D = 2n+1)type IIB\,\,
D(-1)-brane\,\,\,
D1-brane\,\,2d CFT with BH entropy
D3-brane\,\,N=4 D=4 super Yang-Mills theory
D5-brane\,\,\,
D7-brane\,\,\,
D9-brane\,\,\,
(p,q)-string\,\,\,
(D25-brane)(bosonic string theory)
NS-branetype I, II, heteroticcircle n-connection\,
string\,B2-field2d SCFT
NS5-brane\,B6-fieldlittle string theory
D-brane for topological string\,
A-brane\,
B-brane\,
M-brane11D SuGra/M-theorycircle n-connection\,
M2-brane\,C3-fieldABJM theory, BLG model
M5-brane\,C6-field6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT
M9-brane/O9-planeheterotic string theory
M-wave
topological M2-branetopological M-theoryC3-field on G₂-manifold
topological M5-brane\,C6-field on G₂-manifold
S-brane
SM2-brane,
membrane instanton
M5-brane instanton
D3-brane instanton
solitons on M5-brane6d (2,0)-superconformal QFT
self-dual stringself-dual B-field
3-brane in 6d

References

General

That there is a maximal dimension d=11d = 11 in which supergravity may exist was found in

The theory was then actually constructed (as a Lagrangian field theory) in

The claim of the derivation of D=11D=11 supergravity in supergeometry, by solving the torsion constraint and Bianchi identities on super spacetime supermanifolds (“superspace”) is due to

and in the mild variation (using a manifestly duality-symmetric super-C-field flux density) in:

A proof of this claim is laid out in

using further lemmas and then heavy computer algebra checks (here).

On the component expansion of the fields on superspace:

With focus on the Kaluza-Klein compactification to 4d anti de Sitter spacetime:

The history as of the 1990s, with an eye towards the development to M-theory:

The description of 11d supergravity in terms of the D'Auria-Fré-Regge formulation of supergravity originates in

of which a textbook account is in

reviewed again in

The topological deformation (almost) noticed in equation (4.25) of D’Auria-Fre 82 later reappears in (4.13) of

and around (4.2) of Tsimpis 04

The D'Auria-Fré formulation is a first-order formulation of D=11D=11 supergravity; for more on this see:

More recent textbook accounts include

Discussion of the equivalence of the 11d SuGra equations of motion with the supergravity torsion constraints is in

following

Much computational detail is displayed in

On manifestly supersymmetric action functionals for 11D supergravity via pure spinor superfields on superspace:

Further discussion in terms of pure spinors:

Duality-symmetric formulation

Formulation of the equations of motion of D=11 supergravity in superspace on fields including a flux density G 7G_7 a priori independent of the flux density G 4G_4 of the supergravity C-field:

Discussion of Lagrangian densities for D=11 supergravity with an a priori independent dual C-field field and introduction of the “duality-symmetric” terminology:

Discussion in the context of shifted C-field flux quantization:

Supergravity CC-Field gauge algebra

Identifying the super-graded gauge algebra of the C-field in D=11 supergravity (with non-trivial super Lie bracket [v 3,v 3]=−v 6[v_3, v_3] = -v_6):

See also:

Identification as an L ∞ L_\infty -algebra (a dg-Lie algebra, in this case):

and identificatoin with the rational Whitehead L ∞ L_\infty -algebra (the rational Quillen model) of the 4-sphere (cf. Hypothesis H):

Classical solutions and BPS states

Bosonic solutions of eleven-dimensional supergravity were studied in the 1980s in the context of Kaluza-Klein supergravity. The topic received renewed attention in the mid-to-late 1990s as a result of the branes and duality paradigm and the AdS/CFT correspondence.

One of the earliest solutions of eleven-dimensional supergravity is the maximally supersymmetric Freund-Rubin compactification with geometry AdS 4×S 7AdS_4 \times S^7 and 4-form flux proportional to the volume form on AdS 4AdS_4.

  • Peter Freund, Mark Rubin, Dynamics of Dimensional Reduction Phys.Lett. B97 (1980) 233-235 (inSpire)

The radii of curvatures of the two factors are furthermore in a ratio of 1:2. The modern avatar of this solution is as the near-horizon geometry of coincident M2-branes.

Shortly after the original Freund-Rubin solution was discovered, Englert discovered a deformation of this solution where one could turn on flux on the S 7S^7; namely, singling out one of the Killing spinors of the solution, a suitable multiple of the 4-form one constructs by squaring the spinor can be added to the volume form in AdS 4AdS_4 and the resulting 4-form still obeys the supergravity field equations, albeit with a different relation between the radii of curvature of the two factors. The flux breaks the SO(8) symmetry of the sphere to an SO(7)SO(7) subgroup.

  • Francois Englert, Spontaneous Compactification of Eleven-Dimensional Supergravity Phys.Lett. B119 (1982) 339 (inSPIRE)

Some of the above is taken from this TP.SE thread.

See also

Classification of symmetric solutions:

Discussion of black branes and BPS states:

Discussion of AdS 3 AdS_3 solutions with two 3-sphere-factors (products AdS 3×S 3×S 3×Σ 2AdS_3 \times S^3 \times S^3 \times \Sigma^2 warped over a surface Σ 2\Sigma^2, being near horizon geometries of certain M2-M5-brane bound states):

Discussion of (black hole) event horizons:

See also:

  • Teng Fei, Bin Guo, Duong H. Phong, A Geometric Construction of Solutions to 11D Supergravity [arXiv:1805.07506]

  • Emanuele Di Bella, Willem A. de Graaf, Andrea Santi: Some rigidity results for supergravity backgrounds in 11 dimensions [arXiv:2603.19923]

  • Andrea Conti: 𝒩=3\mathcal{N}=3 supersymmetric AdS 4AdS_4 solutions in d=11d=11 supergravity [arXiv:2610.00468]

Resolution of scalar field-dressed Schwarzschild black holes in D=11 supergravity:

Higher curvature corrections to D=11D=11 supergravity

See the discussion of the corrections, their physical origin and the open problems.

Reviews and overviews

Anomaly cancellation and the gravitational Chern–Simons coupling

For the physical origin of C 3∧I 8C_3\wedge I_8, compare the type IIA one-loop calculation with inflow for a magnetic M5-brane. The corresponding superspace problem is described below.

Superspace deformation theory

Relaxed torsion constraints and spinorial cohomology
Anomaly-corrected Bianchi identities and the superform action principle

See also the superspace discussion at I 8I_8.

Component supersymmetry and the Noether procedure

Generalized Lichnerowicz formula

  • André Coimbra, Ruben Minasian, M-theoretic Lichnerowicz formula and supersymmetry, JHEP 10 (2019) 036. §6.1 discusses the further flux terms required in the higher-derivative construction. arXiv:1705.04330, doi

Eleven-dimensional scattering amplitudes and counterterms

  • Michael Green, Michael Gutperle, Pierre Vanhove, One loop in eleven dimensions, Physics Letters B 409 (1997) 177–184. Equation (11) separates the zero-winding contribution from the radius-dependent term reproducing the type IIA tree amplitude. arXiv:hep-th/9706175

  • Jorge Russo, Arkady Tseytlin, One-loop four-graviton amplitude in eleven-dimensional supergravity, Nuclear Physics B 508 (1997) 245–259. arXiv:hep-th/9707134

  • Stanley Deser, Domenico Seminara, Counterterms/M-theory Corrections to D=11D=11 Supergravity, Physical Review Letters 82 (1999) 2435–2438. arXiv:hep-th/9812136, doi

  • Michael Green, Hwang-h. Kwon, Pierre Vanhove, Two loops in eleven dimensions, Physical Review D 61 (2000) 104010. arXiv:hep-th/9910055, doi

  • Stanley Deser, Domenico Seminara, Tree Amplitudes and Two-loop Counterterms in D=11D=11 Supergravity, Physical Review D 62 (2000) 084010. arXiv:hep-th/0002241, doi

  • Lilia Anguelova, Pietro Antonio Grassi, Pierre Vanhove, Covariant One-Loop Amplitudes in D=11D=11, Nuclear Physics B 702 (2004) 269–306. §6.2 extracts the C 3∧X 8C_3\wedge X_8 tensor structure from a five-point calculation. arXiv:hep-th/0408171, doi

  • Kasper Peeters, Jan Plefka, Steffen Stern, Higher-derivative gauge field terms in the M-theory action, JHEP 08 (2005) 095. arXiv:hep-th/0507178

Dimensional reduction, string amplitudes and duality

  • David J. Gross, Edward Witten, Superstring Modifications of Einstein’s Equations, Nuclear Physics B 277 (1986) 1–10. doi

  • Edward Witten, String Theory Dynamics in Various Dimensions, Nuclear Physics B 443 (1995) 85–126. §2 identifies the eleven-dimensional interpretation of the strong-coupling limit of type IIA. arXiv:hep-th/9503124, doi

  • Ignatios Antoniadis, Sergio Ferrara, Ruben Minasian, Kumar S. Narain, R 4R^4 Couplings in M and Type II Theories, Nuclear Physics B 507 (1997) 571–588. arXiv:hep-th/9707013

  • Michael Green, Pierre Vanhove, Duality and higher derivative terms in M theory, JHEP 01 (2006) 093. arXiv:hep-th/0510027

  • James Liu, Ruben Minasian, Higher-derivative couplings in string theory: dualities and the B-field, Nuclear Physics B 874 (2013) 413–470. arXiv:1304.3137, doi

  • Anirban Basu, Constraining gravitational interactions in the M theory effective action, Classical and Quantum Gravity 31 (2014) 165007. arXiv:1308.2564, doi

  • Hamid R. Bakhtiarizadeh, Gauge field corrections to 11-dimensional supergravity via dimensional reduction, European Physical Journal C 78 (2018) 686. arXiv:1711.11313, doi

  • James Liu, Ruben Minasian, Raffaele Savelli, Andreas Schachner, Type IIB at eight derivatives: insights from Superstrings, Superfields and Superparticles, JHEP 08 (2022) 267. arXiv:2205.11530, doi

  • Mohammad R. Garousi, Type IIA supergravity at one loop: α′ 3\alpha'^3 terms in the metric-dilaton-RR one-form sector, JHEP 11 (2025) 105. arXiv:2508.10529, doi

  • Mohammad R. Garousi, Dimensional reduction of the M-theory Chern-Simons term at order ℓ p 6\ell_p^6, Physical Review D 112 (2025) 106019. arXiv:2509.13726, doi

  • Aviral Aggarwal, Subhroneel Chakrabarti, Steven Weilong Hsia, Ahmed Rakin Kamal, Linus Wulff, One loop in D=11D=11 vs D=10D=10: 4-point check, JHEP 02 (2026) 010. The published version finds agreement with type IIA in the NSNS and Ramond–Ramond sectors examined, correcting the discrepancy reported in the first preprint. arXiv:2506.16391, doi

Comparison with five-dimensional supergravity

  • Kentaro Hanaki, Keisuke Ohashi, Yuji Tachikawa, Supersymmetric Completion of an R 2R^2 Term in Five-Dimensional Supergravity, Progress of Theoretical Physics 117 (2007) 533–556. Constructs the completion of the mixed gauge–gravitational Chern–Simons term. arXiv:hep-th/0611329, doi

  • Federico Bonetti, Thomas W. Grimm, Stefan Hohenegger, One-loop Chern-Simons terms in five dimensions, JHEP 07 (2013) 043. Calculates the shifts from integrating out massive fields. arXiv:1302.2918, doi

Bases of gauge-invariant effective couplings

  • Mohammad R. Garousi, Minimal gauge invariant couplings at order ℓ p 6\ell_p^6 in M-theory, Nuclear Physics B 977 (2022) 115733. Classifies bosonic couplings modulo field redefinitions, Bianchi identities and total derivatives. arXiv:2102.00639, doi

Exceptional symmetry and the E 10E_{10} proposal

Holographic constraints on eleven-dimensional interactions

  • Arkady Tseytlin, R 4R^4 terms in 11 dimensions and conformal anomaly of (2,0)(2,0) theory, Nuclear Physics B 584 (2000) 233–250. arXiv:hep-th/0005072

  • Shai Chester, Silviu S. Pufu, Xi Yin, The M-Theory S-Matrix From ABJM: Beyond 11D Supergravity, JHEP 08 (2018) 115. Obtains the flat-space R 4R^4 coefficient from an ABJM correlator. See (1.1)–(1.3) and footnote 9 for normalizations. arXiv:1804.00949, doi

  • Shai Chester, Eric Perlmutter, M-Theory Reconstruction from (2,0)(2,0) CFT and the Chiral Algebra Conjecture, JHEP 08 (2018) 116. arXiv:1805.00892, doi

  • Damon J. Binder, Shai Chester, Silviu S. Pufu, Absence of D 4R 4D^4R^4 in M-Theory From ABJM, JHEP 04 (2020) 052. arXiv:1808.10554, doi

  • Shai Chester, Ross Dempsey, Silviu S. Pufu, Higher-derivative corrections in M-theory from precision numerical bootstrap, JHEP 07 (2025) 096. §3.2 gives numerical estimates for CFT data sensitive to the unprotected D 8R 4D^8R^4 interaction. arXiv:2412.14094, doi

Matrix theory

Compactifications and applications

Flux compactifications and special holonomy
Lower-dimensional effective supergravity and holography
Cosmology and de Sitter vacua

These papers study cosmological solutions of particular truncated effective actions.

Scattering amplitudes and Effective action

Computation of Feynman amplitudes/scattering amplitudes and effective action in 11d supergravity:

Via worldline formalism:

  • Max Guillen, Marcelo dos Santos, Eggon Viana: Tree-level 11D supergravity amplitudes from the pure spinor worldline [arXiv:2508.19748]

Truncations and compactifications

Kaluza-Klein compactifications of supergravity and its consistent truncations:

Discussion of Freund-Rubin compactifications:

KK-Reduction of 11D SuGra on CY 3CY^3s to 5D SuGra

Discussion of KK-compactification of D=11 supergravity on Calabi-Yau 3-folds to D=5 supergravity (cf. M-theory on Calabi-Yau manifolds):

See also:

For 11D Sugra with M9-branes (Hořava-Witten theory):

Topology and anomaly cancellation

Discussion of quantum anomaly cancellation and Green-Schwarz mechanism in 11D supergravity includes the following articles. (For more see at M5-brane – anomaly cancellation).

Description by exceptional generalized geometry

Review of U-duality and exceptional generalized geometry in KK-compactification of D=11 supergravity:

Last revised on November 10, 2026 at 17:44:04. See the history of this page for a list of all contributions to it.